about us | newsletter | contact | archive | members area
Gheorghe Ciubotaru, Electroalfa
We are witnessing a continuous process of adaptation to the mechanisms in the market»
  Features:      COUNTRY FOCUS   |   SECTOR ANALYSIS   |

Ringleader of brands

Shopping centre pioneer and CEO of Baneasa Developments Ali Ergun Ergen reveals how to keep a mall healthy during and beyond the recession. Profile by Corina Ilie

September 2010 - From the Print Edition

In 2006 and 2007 Romania was trapped in a development frenzy of shopping centres, with up to six set to open in cities such as Arad and Ploiesti at the same time. Since then some projects have vanished, some were so indebted the developers sold them below their building cost and many are not bringing their investors the returns they anticipated.
So is this really the best time to be running a mall?
There are opportunities. The financial crisis flushed out many low quality retailers and left room for large international fashion brands, such as Sweden’s H&M and Spain’s Zara, to find space to grow. Some malls in places which serviced a small catchment areas or had a wrong tenant mix or poor management have also not opened, allowing the existing competition to seize their tenants.
When the crisis ends, the market will be split between profitable shopping centres in good locations, which can expand, and bankrupt malls, some of which will need to find a new role, argues Ali Ergun Ergen, CEO of Baneasa Developments, the developer of north Bucharest’s Baneasa Shopping City.
“I do not see any new shopping centre projects in the next few years,” says Ergen.
A lack of finance and more retailers asking for a cut in rents or extra benefits to open inside a mall are the main reasons why developers cannot keep investing in shopping centres. “Under these circumstances it is almost impossible to build a new retail scheme,” says Ergen. “Tenants are asking not only for lower rents, but also fit-up contributions from [the mall] owners.”
The CEO believes many shopping centre owners lost their tenants and customers due to poor management and an overcrowding of malls in the same area. Ergen says the unexpected expansion of the retail market in the years before the crisis was based - in many cases - on developers having access to a piece of land, rather than having a clear strategy that this was the right place to build a successful business.
Many developers did not pay attention to the tenant mix, as long as they cashed in rents in the short-term. Over time, this has proven to be a poor strategy as low performing brands closed down. Ergen says the crisis has changed the owners’ approach towards the tenants and the tenants’ approach to shopping centres. “The owner-tenant relationship has never been as tense before now,” says the CEO.
Situated in Bucharest’s affluent north and opened in 2008, Baneasa Shopping City is a mall in a complex which includes Ikea, Bricostore and Carrefour. The mall is planning the expansion with three new areas - a 15,000 sqm multiplex cinema, an entertainment area including bowling, billiards and video games and a petrol station. This is a 22 million Euro investment and will cover 35,000 sqm of the Baneasa project’s shopping area.
The centre is 97 per cent rented, but tenants who have seen sales constantly going down could no longer stay in the centre, while the rents of others, which had more chances to recover, were renegotiated.
“We approached the retailers before they came to us and we told them that their sales seemed to be going down and we tried to find a better strategy together, where it was possible,” says Ergen. “The renegotiation of the rent is a very complex process. We have to analyse carefully a lot of parameters and compare a low performing store with others of the same type, to see if it is profitable to keep.”
The CEO says the mall also had tenants with low sales, who were willing to pay even higher rents to keep their stores open, but the owner did not keep them, as they did not offer a profitable proposal in the long-term.
The departure of smaller, low performing retailers and a more competitive rental proposition has created possibilities for big international fashion chains, some of them willing to enter Romania this year and the next. H&M will open in Bucharest’s AFI Palace Cotroceni, Bucuresti Mall, Plaza Romania and, in spring 2011, in Baneasa Shopping City. Baneasa Developments started the negotiations with H&M in 2006.
Two more international brands - one addressed to women and both new on the Romania market - will open stores inside Baneasa Shopping City in November and in spring 2011. According to Ergen more international brands will open in Romania and other eastern European countries, because the growth potential has reached certain limits in western Europe. Moreover, brands which entered the country by franchise before the crisis, so they did not risk their own revenues in an untested market, will start opening stores directly.
“The market is not very mature yet, but there is enough retail stock for at least five or six major cities and investors can now easily collect statistics about the potential of these cities,” says the CEO.
International brand franchisers have opened larger size concepts in Romania lately, similar to those in western Europe. According to Ergen, three years ago the franchisers were afraid to open larger stores. After the beginning of the crisis, the store sizes have increased from around 150 sqm to 200 to 250 sqm on average.
But retailers are more careful about selecting shopping centres where they want to be present. Before the crisis, retailers aimed to open stores in as many shopping centres and look at the overall profit – but now they have realised that some stores are unprofitable, because they target a different demographic to that of the shopping mall.
“Priorities have changed,” he says. “Now retailers are selecting shopping centres by location and prefer central locations where the traffic is higher. They have more knowledge, they are more educated and they negotiate better with the owners.”
Many retailers closed their stores in the country at large to keep those in Bucharest, where sales were higher. “Retailers expanded so fast in Romania, before the crisis, because the sales in Bucharest were supporting the low sales in other cities,” says Ergen. “When they opened stores in other cities they never thought about parameters such as customers and average income.”


Turkish Ali Ergun Ergen has been one of the chief pioneers of the development of large-scale shopping centres in Romania. Before becoming CEO of Baneasa Developments in 2005, he spent five years as general manager of the Turkish Anchor Grup, where he coordinated the development of the first malls opened in Romania - Bucuresti Mall in Vitan and Plaza Romania on Blvd. Timisoara - both in Bucharest. Before coming to Romania, he was a planning engineer and planning chief for projects in Turkey, Turkmenistan and Kazakhstan.
Ergen graduated from the Istanbul Technical University as a civil engineer and enjoys travelling, reading and playing tennis.

There are 0 comments:

Validation Code

0 Comments  |  14066 Views
Daily Info
President Iohannis: Interconnection projects revealed at Three Seas Initiative summit are a top level political signal

The list of priority interconnection projects presented within the Summit of the Three Seas Initiative is "a top level political signal", on Tuesday stated Klaus Iohannis, in ...

Vodafone to lay off 1,700 service center employees in Romania, India and Egypt

Vodafone, one of the biggest telecom groups in the world, will lay off 1,700 employees from its service centers in Romania, India and Egypt, in this financial year, the group'...

European Property Federation elects Liviu Tudor as new President

The European Property Federation Managing Committee elected Liviu Tudor, CEO of Genesis Property and President of the Romanian Association of Building Owners, as President of ...

Commisioner Cretu: Romania has a high level of women representation in the digital sector

Romania is one of the countries of the European Union with a high level of representation of women in the digital sector, said European Commissioner for Regional Policy, Corin...

Romania gets 450 million Euro loan from EIB for rural development programme

The European Investment Bank (EIB) is lending 450 million Euro to Romania to finance its national contribution to the implementation of the Romanian Rural Development Programm...






More on Features
US calls for coherent, long-term strategy

As USA celebrates 4th of July, its eyes are wide open on the latest developments in Romania's ongoing struggle for the rule of law. Still, the country is one of the fastest...

French investments at a glance: Interest still high

France, Romania's fourth largest foreign direct investor, has been around since the early 1990s, with flagship names the likes of Societe Generale or Groupe Renault taking ...

Romanian energy industry: Challenges to Overcome

With a national strategy draft still to be approved, Romania faces many challenges, as the energy market is striving to find a way to attract major investments that are cri...

Rising potential for green developments

With GDP growth outperforming neighbouring CEE countries by a significant extent, 2017 was very good for the real estate market in Romania, especially for the office, inves...

EnergyPal: The market must invest in innovation and develop worker qualifications

Romania's facility management sector in 2017 has seen changes in terms of increased market dynamic due to new office developments and also logistic sector growth, according...

Romanian office market ripening, in both leasing and acquisition

From the investment standpoint, lower rates of return and increased liquidity lure the investors, Andreea Paun, Managing Partner, Griffes said in an interview for The Diplo...

ISS: External FM market volume will grow as more Western European FM companies open subsidiaries in Romania

In the last few years as well as in 2017, the Romanian FM market has been in the process of maturing, focusing more and more on quality, efficiency and added value, demandi...