about us | newsletter | contact | archive | members area
Tal Roma, AFI Europe Romania
In 2017, the companies were facing a more competitive labour market»
  Features:      COUNTRY FOCUS   |   SECTOR ANALYSIS   |

No escape from the fair deal

From catching scheming hoteliers, probing petrol stations to opening up the notary market, President of the Competition Council Bogdan Chiritoiu talks cartel-busting to Ana Maria Nitoi

November 2009 - From the Print Edition

Last June sleepy spa resort for sick pensioners Baile Olanesti in Valcea county was rocked by the arrival of Competition Council’s inspectors, as they swooped down in a raid on seven hoteliers.
The businesses were suspected of having made some understandings between one another to bid separately for public tenders subsidising hotel rooms for pensioners.
One company, Olanesti Riviera, received a 23,000 Euro penalty for refusing to allow inspectors to check its documents and emails. Meanwhile another, Sind Romania, was penalised with 13,000 Euro for attempting to destroy documents during the inspection.
“Usually multinationals to do not resist our searches, while smaller companies, who do not understand what the Competition Council does, make attempts [at a cover-up] like in Baile Olanesti,” says Bogdan Chiritoiu, the president of the Competition Council.
From large corporates to two-star hoteliers, the Competition Council inspectors have great liberty when investigating a case of a possible cartel. They can ask for any information regarding the investigation from the companies involved and, if they are refused, the penalties are high. The Council can also use a surprise inspection at the same time at different companies or at several locations of the same firm – a dawn raid. “Generally, we do a maximum of one inspection per case and it is then when we put our hands on the most significant information,” says Chiritoiu.
Now the Council is working on 45 major investigations into a possible breach of competition law. From these, 14 have been opened in the last five months since Chiritoiu became president.
Speeding up the process of probes is his priority. “When I came here I found that some investigations had been open since 2004, which is unacceptable and I have to reorganise measures to get things moving faster,” says Chiritoiu.
The average in the EU for finalising an investigation is between 16 and 18 months, while in Romania this is almost two and a half years. For cases older than two years, Chiritoiu has changed or replaced the investigation heads to bring a new perspective.
One large-scale investigation, started more than four years ago, is examining whether there were understandings between companies regarding the prices of petrol products. Last September the Council decided to search the offices of the six largest petrol retailers in Romania - Petrom, Rompetrol, Lukoil, Mol, OMV and Agip. This investigation is still ongoing.
Recently one decision ruled in favour of Greek mobile operator Cosmote’s purchase of Saudi Arabian rival Zapp in Romania. “In principle we agree with the idea of the consolidation of a third actor [Cosmote] in a sector where there are already two very strong players [Orange and Vodafone],” says Chiritoiu.

Trial hold-up

But an obstacle to the council is that most penalties are contested in court, with a trial lasting up to three years. The council is trying to promote a modification of the competition law by the beginning of 2010. “We want to introduce a highly used practice in the EU - clemency - meaning that if a company recognises its fault during an investigation, it is forgiven, while the second firm that comes to us and admits its guilt benefits from a reduction in the penalty,” says the president. This should encourage evidence gathering. If a penalty is up to ten per cent of the turnover of a company, the Council could cut by 50 per cent the penalty. This change depends on whether MPs will pass the new legislation.
The role and number of notaries in the real estate sector are also under analysis, where the Council has recommended changing legislation to encourage competition. Now there is a limited number of notaries allowed to operate on the market. In addition, they are not allowed to promote their services. The Council wants to enlarge their number and facilitate competition by allowing them to advertise. The hope is that this will bring down their fees. “We estimate that about 300 million Euro every year could be saved to the benefit of consumers if our recommendations are put in place,” says Chiritoiu.
The president’s approach is more about prevention than punishment. “My goal is to encourage competition in Romania by finding faults in the legislation and make recommendations to modify this,” he says, “rather than enforcing the competition law by imposing sanctions, without solving the core problems.”



COMMENTS
There are 0 comments:

 
ADD A COMMENT
 
Name
Email
Comment
Validation Code
   
 
 

0 Comments  |  12756 Views
Daily Info
P3 relocates HQ to Charles de Gaulle Plaza

European investor and developer of logistic properties P3 relocated its headquarters to Charles de Gaulle Plaza, one of the most iconic office buildings in Bucharest, owned by...

Deloitte Romania assists transactions exceeding 500 million Euro in the last three months

Deloitte M&A specialists assisted in transactions exceeding half a billion Euro during the past three months, providing support buy-side and sell-side in M&A, due diligence, t...

Believe in people's potential

"The greatest danger for most of us is not that our aim is too high, and we miss it, but that it is too low, and we reach it." (Michelangelo Buonarroti) This is my motto that ...

Veeam estimates record growth, one billion USD turnover in 2018

Veeam Software posts another quarterly growth, 21 per cent higher than last year. Overall, the financial performance for 2017 was remarkable, with revenues of 827 million USD....

TransferGo attracts 8.6 million Euro financing for international expansion

TransferGo, the international fast online transfer company, has attracted a round of investment of 8.6 million Euro, which is the biggest amount received in a single financing...

 
 
   
advertising

advertising

advertising

advertising

advertising

More on Features
Global efforts to develop low-carbon, energy-efficient solutions

Interview with Robert Tudorache, Secretary of State, Ministry of Energy

Fresh Delivery (P)

Up to speed with the courier sector in an interview with Gian Sharp, CEO at Urgent Cargus

ANCOM: We look at the postal services market in the light of e-commerce developments

Romania's courier business is pretty dynamic these days and tends to become more and more high-tech as players are trying to find innovative solutions to keep up with users...

High potential for sustainable growth on Romanian FM market

Facility Management is still a developing market in Romania, with a lot of challenges to overcome. The Romanian Facility Management Association (ROFMA) analyses the relevan...

Rising potential for green developments

With GDP growth outperforming neighbouring CEE countries by a significant extent, 2017 was very good for the real estate market in Romania, especially for the office, inves...

EnergyPal: The market must invest in innovation and develop worker qualifications

Romania's facility management sector in 2017 has seen changes in terms of increased market dynamic due to new office developments and also logistic sector growth, according...

Romanian office market ripening, in both leasing and acquisition

From the investment standpoint, lower rates of return and increased liquidity lure the investors, Andreea Paun, Managing Partner, Griffes said in an interview for The Diplo...